Seven symptoms account for most water heater failures: no hot water, hot water that runs out early, rusty water on the hot side, rumbling or popping, moisture at the base, a dripping temperature-and-pressure relief valve, and a tank that has reached the end of its service life. Most of these give you days or weeks to act. One does not. Water coming out of the tank itself means the heater is finished, and every hour it stays pressurized adds to the damage.
The order below is by urgency, not by how common each one is. If you read only one section, read the first.
1. Water at the base of the tank
A puddle under a water heater usually comes from one of three places: a fitting on the inlet or outlet pipe, the relief valve, or the tank shell. The first two can often be repaired. A shell leak cannot: the lining has corroded through from the inside, and sealant on the outside will not close it.
Shut the unit down before you investigate:
- Cut the heat source. For an electric heater, switch off its breaker, but do not reach into a wet panel or stand in water to do it. For a gas heater, turn the control knob to OFF. Do not disconnect the gas line or attempt a repair on it.
- Close the cold-water inlet valve on top of the tank. Turn the handle until it stops. If it is an old valve that will not move, leave it and shut the house main instead.
- Move anything nearby that water can ruin. A weeping tank can let go completely, and the water will still be hot.
A gas smell is not a plumbing call
If you smell gas near the heater, do not flip switches, light anything, or try to relight the pilot. Leave the building and call your gas utility or 911 from outside.
If water is spreading toward a finished room or an electrical outlet, stop the flow first and treat the call as urgent. A confirmed tank leak is one of the situations covered on the emergency plumbing page.
2. The relief valve is dripping
The temperature-and-pressure valve, usually labeled T&P, is the safety device that keeps a tank from becoming a pressure vessel. It should open only when temperature or pressure climbs too high, not drip during normal operation.
Three things cause a drip: a valve that no longer seats, a closed system with nowhere for expanding water to go, or house pressure that is genuinely too high. A plumber can test the pressure with a gauge rather than guess which one it is.
Never cap, plug, or block a T&P valve to stop a drip. It is the last line of defense against an overheated tank, and disabling it turns a nuisance leak into a hazard.
If the valve will not reseat after it has opened, or if water is running rather than dripping, shut off the heater and treat it as urgent. The discharge pipe should lead to a drain or end close to the floor, not disappear into a wall or empty into a bucket that someone forgets.
Rather talk it through?One call, answered 24/7. Tell us what is happening and we will check local availability.
(888) 538-06643. No hot water at all
Check the simple causes first. For an electric heater, look at the breaker. A breaker that trips again right after you reset it is telling you something is wrong with the circuit or the element, and it should stay off until someone tests it. For a gas heater, confirm the control is on and the pilot is lit or the ignition is firing.
A pilot that lights and then dies within a minute is worth a service call. Repeated relighting is not a fix, and it can be unsafe if the problem involves venting or the gas valve. If you smell gas at any point, leave and call the utility from outside.
If fuel and power are both fine, the likely suspects are a heating element, a thermostat, or a control board. Testing them takes a meter and a working knowledge of the sequence; swapping parts one at a time is guesswork.
4. Hot water runs out sooner than it used to
A shower that once lasted fifteen minutes and now fades in five points to a storage problem. In a tank heater, sediment on the bottom eats into the volume that holds hot water. A failed dip tube does something similar: it should carry cold water to the bottom of the tank, and when it breaks off, cold water mixes near the outlet instead.
Run hot water at a tub and watch it over several minutes. If it starts strong and then drops sharply, the tank is emptying too fast. If it never gets fully hot, suspect the dip tube, a thermostat, or a crossed connection at a single-handle faucet.
5. Rusty water on the hot side
Fill a clear glass from the cold tap, then another from the hot tap. If the cold is clear and the hot is brown or yellow, the heater is the source. That usually means the anode rod is spent, sediment has built up, or the lining has started to fail.
An anode rod is sacrificial: it corrodes so the tank does not. Replacing one on a tank with years left can be worthwhile. Rusty water from a tank that is already old and damp at the fittings usually means the lining is gone, and a new rod will not bring it back.
Flushing may clear a one-time burst of sediment, especially after a utility shutdown or a repair. If the color returns within a week, stop flushing and start planning.
6. Rumbling, popping, or banging
That noise is water trapped under sediment, turning to steam and collapsing. It is most common in hard-water areas and on tanks that have never been flushed. A flush can quiet a tank while the sediment is still loose. If the tank is old and the noise is new, the same layer may have overheated the steel at the bottom.
Do not confuse it with a banging pipe elsewhere in the house. If the sound stops when the heater is off at the breaker, the heater is the source.
7. The tank is old, corroded, or slow to recover
Tank heaters commonly last 8 to 12 years; hard water or heavy use shortens that. Find the label with the model and serial number. The serial usually encodes the build date, and the maker's decoding chart is easy to look up.
Other end-of-life clues: rust at the inlet and outlet fittings, a damp ring at the bottom of the tank, corrosion on the flue, scorching at the top, and insulation that stays wet. Any one of those, combined with age, is a reason to plan a replacement.
Rather talk it through?One call, answered 24/7. Tell us what is happening and we will check local availability.
(888) 538-0664What you can check yourself, safely
- Hot versus cold. Two glasses of water tell you whether the problem is the heater or the whole supply.
- The breaker. Reset it once. If it trips again, leave it off.
- The label. Model, serial, capacity, and fuel type. Photograph it, because the label fades.
- The floor. A paper towel left under the tank overnight shows a seep that a glance misses.
- The discharge pipe. Confirm where the relief valve would send water. If it ends in a wall or has a cap, that needs attention.
What not to do
- Do not cap or plug the T&P valve, and do not remove its handle.
- Do not relight a pilot repeatedly or tape down a control knob.
- Do not open an electrical panel or work on a gas line yourself.
- Do not ignore a burning smell, a scorched wire, or a hot outlet cover near an electric heater. That is a fire concern: turn the breaker off and call for service.
What to tell the plumbing professional
A short, specific report saves diagnostic time:
- Fuel type, tank or tankless, and the model or serial number if it is readable.
- What changed and when: color, noise, temperature, water at the base, a tripped breaker.
- Whether the water is rusty on the hot side only.
- What you have already tried: reset, relight, flush, shutoff.
- Whether anyone has been scalded or the water has run unusually hot.
If the heater sits in a closet, attic, or crawl space, clear access before the visit; damage below the unit may not be visible.
Repair or replace?
A failed element, thermostat, dip tube, or relief valve is a repair. A leaking tank shell is a replacement, full stop. The judgment call is the middle ground: an older tank with a second failure, or one that has been flushed repeatedly and still runs out of hot water.
Two questions help: how old is it, and how many problems has it had in the past two years? A tank near the end of its range, with one repair behind it and another issue developing, is usually better replaced on a weekday than on a holiday. Tankless units have their own service life, and hard water makes descaling a maintenance item.
Ask about the scope before work begins: permit requirements, venting, expansion control, and whether the old unit is hauled away. Those details vary by location and model, so confirm them for your address. More on the water heater repair page.
Rather talk it through?One call, answered 24/7. Tell us what is happening and we will check local availability.
(888) 538-0664Frequently asked questions
Can a leaking water heater be repaired?
If the water comes from a fitting, the relief valve, or a pipe connection, often yes. If the tank shell is wet or rusted through, no. Confirm which one before you authorize work.
Why is my hot water rusty but the cold water clear?
That points at the heater: a spent anode rod, sediment, or a failing lining. Clear cold water means the supply is fine, so the tank is the source.
Is a dripping T&P valve an emergency?
Treat it as urgent rather than as a drip to ignore, and never cap it. Shut off the heater if it is running steadily and have the cause checked. A valve that will not reseat after opening needs replacement.
Should I replace a 10-year-old heater that still works?
Not automatically. If it heats well, shows no rust at the fittings, and has never leaked, keep it and flush it. If it needed a repair in the past year or the hot water is discolored, plan ahead rather than wait for it to fail.